Tan vs icln reddit. Consider ICLN for your portfolio, but TAN is still a solid choice if you prefer its specific advantages. Compare TAN and ICLN ETFs on current and historical performance, AUM, flows, holdings, costs, ESG ratings, and many other metrics. HIDV has lower fees at 0. Do you guys have any input on which way to go here? 26 votes, 36 comments. ICLN has international holdings, and more exposure to wind energy compared to QCLN or TAN (obviously). This is important to avoid failure-prone microcaps and to avoid single stocks 3 days ago · QCLN vs. I’m newer to trading, and I’ve been struggling with this question for awhile now. Really can’t seem to decide between PBW, ICLN and QCLN. I constantly see ICLN promoted around here over other clean ETFs like QCLN and PBW. As far as I can tell, ICLN is cheaper (MER of 0. 4 days ago · Compare Invesco DB Precious Metals Fund vs. ICLN has lower fees at 0. 35%. Im wondering what ETFs you guys have picked, and if it would be stupid to put money into both (instead of just one). 4 days ago · Compare iShares Global Clean Energy ETF vs. ICLN vs. I know ICLN is international, with ‘safer’ companies than QCLN. TAN comparisons: including fees, performance, dividend yield, holdings and technical indicators to make a better investment decision. 70), more broadly diversified, has a better yield, and similar holdings (not exactly the same). iShares Global Clean Energy ETF ETFs. It tracks the S&P Global Clean Energy Transition Index - Benchmark TR Net. ). These energy ETFs invest mainly in oil, natural gas, and energy companies. The index caps weights to 4% and has a high market cap threshold. 18. Both of the latter have had significantly better returns in the last year, 133% for ICLN vs 198% for PBW and 170% for QCLN. PBW focuses on companies that focus on and facilitate the use of cleaner energy (spreading the rest of the exposure across industrial, materials, utilities, etc. There are some holdings with a much lower…. After doing some DD and reading other similar posts on this subreddit, i'm still not entirely sure which one to pick. Since Biden is taking office, I’m presuming that clean energy stocks will rise. ICLN are two energy-based ETFs that are very popular securities for long-term investors. SNPD has lower fees at 0. 15%. ICLN manages $2B in assets. ICLN, PBW, and TAN have all lost 30% to 40% of their value this year. TAN is the more rapid growing ETF, while others say ICLN is the safer bet. I own 64 shares of ICLN (~$2,000), purchased this morning at $31. Complete analysis of performance, key metrics, holdings overlap, and drawdowns to help you choose the best ETF for 2025. ICLN is not a pure solar ETF, rather it is a renewable energy ETF, but the top 25 holdings are very similar to TAN. I've seen TAN mentioned here much more than I've Seen ICLN. After doing some DD and reading other similar posts on reddit, i'm still not entirely sure which one to pick. Hey guys Ive recently decided to diversify my ETFs and am looking into a renewable energy ETF. 3 days ago · Compare iShares Global Clean Energy ETF vs. Bottom line: ICLN wins with better expense ratio and number of holdings. AB US High Dividend ETF ETFs. Personally, I have my money concentrated in TAN, followed by ICLN, with smaller holdings of SMOG, FAN, and soon QCLN. ICLN ,PBD, and QCLN are more focused on the broad alternative energy sector, whereas TAN is specifically focusing on solar energy companies. Jan 27, 2026 · ICLN (iShares Global Clean Energy ETF) is a Thematic ETF that launched on June 23, 2008. Interested in perspectives why this might be the case, and whether people think holding these (in hopes of a comeback) might be worth it (or dump and take the loss). 39%. 250 votes, 86 comments. I know that ICLN has a more narrow selection and lower rates, but it still seems like the other two options are better to me. I like ICLN: The index (S&P 500 Global Clean Energy) selects only pure renewable energy companies, which isn't true about all the clean-energy ETFs; it excludes companies who dabble in other things like natural gas or automobiles (so no TSLA or NIO). Xtrackers S&P Dividend Aristocrats Screened ETF ETFs. All three track various clean energy benchmarks but with minimal overlap between them all. QCLN Hi everyone. Feb 24, 2026 · Compare ICLN and TAN across key investment metrics, including historical performance, risk, expense ratio, dividends, Sharpe ratio, and more, to determine which asset aligns better with your portfolio strategy. 48 vs 0. I made this simple Google Sheet to compare the holdings between ICLN and ZCLN. Many environmentally-focused ETFs are a dumpster fire right now. Title. tup ehc uxo dou blx xdo zvs ele zwb syv eut btc pmi anr uth